Wimbledon’s AI Technology Receives Heavy Criticism from Tennis Professionals
The Telegraph has reported that certain tennis players are dissatisfied with Wimbledon’s new AI line judges.
Human line judges, who determine whether a ball is in or out, were supplanted by an electronic line calling system (ELC) for the inaugural year of the prestigious tennis tournament, which is currently in progress.
The AI technology was the subject of criticism from a number of participants, primarily due to the fact that it made incorrect judgments, resulting in the loss of points.
Emma Raducanu, a British tennis player, criticized the technology for failing to detect a ball that her opponent had hit out, instead requiring it to be played as if it had been hit in.
The Telegraph reported that the ball did indeed appear to be in the outfield during a television replay.
Jack Draper, the British No. 1, also expressed his belief that certain line calls were incorrect, stating that he did not believe the AI technology was “100 percent accurate.”
The new AI line system was on the brink of malfunctioning due to the diminishing sunlight, necessitating that player Ben Shelton accelerate his match.
In other instances, players reported that the new automated speaker system was inaudible.
One deaf player stated that she was unable to determine whether she had won a point or not without the human hand signals from the line judges.
The technology encountered a glitch at a critical juncture during a match between the Russian Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova and the British player Sonay Kartal this weekend.
The ball was deemed out of play, but the technology was unable to make the correct decision.
The rally was halted by the umpire, who instructed the participants to replay the point due to the ELC’s failure to monitor the point.
Wimbledon subsequently issued an apology, stating that the technology was inadvertently turned off during the match due to a “human error.”
It also made technological adjustments to prevent the recurrence of the error.
Debbie Jevans, the chair of the All England Club, the organization that sponsors Wimbledon, responded to Raducanu and Draper by stating, “We were frequently asked why we did not have electronic line calling because it is more accurate than the rest of the tour when we did have linesmen.”
The AI technology has been the subject of criticism on numerous occasions, as tennis tournaments continue to implement automated systems in varying degrees.
In April, Alexander Zverev, a German player, criticized the automated line judgment technology by publishing a photo to Instagram that clearly demonstrated that a ball that was ruled in was in fact out.
The critiques demonstrate the difficulty of entirely replacing humans with AI, thereby arguing that a human-AI balance may be necessary as more organizations implement this technology.
Klarna recently announced that it was in the process of recruiting human employees, following its previous advocacy for automated employment.
news via inbox
Get the latest updates delivered straight to your inbox. Subscribe now!